Summary: It sounds almost trite to say it, but yes, running Boston is a great experience. I came close to going under three hours with on-plan execution through mile 23, but faded very near the end and did 3:03:57, placing #1610 of around 22,000 finishers. Here are my official splits:
|
Total |
Split |
Pace |
5k |
20:58 |
20:58 |
6:46 |
10k |
42:04 |
21:06 |
6:48 |
15k |
1:03:03 |
20:59 |
6:46 |
20k |
1:24:12 |
21:09 |
6:49 |
Half |
1:28:46 |
1:28:46 |
6:47 |
25k |
1:45:18 |
21:06 |
6:48 |
30k |
2:06:53 |
21:35 |
6:58 |
35k |
2:28:50 |
21:57 |
7:05 |
40k |
2:51:48 |
22:58 |
7:25 |
Finish |
3:03:57 |
12:09 |
8:41 |
The Boston Globe has a great site with lots of photos and stories from race day. Official race results are available here.
Pre-race: Typically in my race reports I skip background on what happened before the race, since it usually has little to do with race performance. The Boston Marathon experience, however, is about much more than the race itself. Here are some notable parts of the experience for me:
- Lots of training. Lots. Training through the winter months is very different than training in Seattle’s great summer weather.
- Supporting my father’s training and fundraising. He won the Boston Marathon Team in Training fundraising effort by raising more money than any of the other ~150 folks on the team.
- Watching the Women’s Olympic Trials was a great addition to the weekend.
- Logistics. With something like 25,000 people entered in the marathon, there are ENORMOUS logistics involved. For example, we had to get on buses at 6:30am to get out to Hopkinton for the 10am start of my wave. The picture at right shows me and my father at the then-quiet finish line at about 6am, just before we headed over to the buses.
- Studying for the Boston Marathon. Since this race is a pretty big deal for marathons, there is lots of information about it. 26 Miles To Boston is a pretty good historical reference. A particularly good posting with race tips is Boston Marathon, Tips to get you to the Finish Line. Someone created an amazing spreadsheet with tons of info including a Boston-specific pace calculator.
- The pre-race atmosphere at the "Athlete’s Village" was a lot of fun. There is a huge amount of excitement and anticipation in the air as everyone readies for the big event. The port-a-potty lines weren’t too bad.
- As we headed to the start line, someone was handing out cheap gloves for the runners to wear. This was great, because it was a little chilly, but by that time we had all handed in all of our non-essential clothes to the buses to take to the finish line for us.
- Unlike any race I have done, they seed people in corrals by qualifying time, so you are running near others of roughly similar expected time. For a race this size, this is essential, as otherwise it would be a total mess for the first few miles.
- One of the best tips from the the Twenty Six Two site involves a Gatorade bottle and a garbage bag. I’ll not detail it here–just search for "Gatorade" on that link. My wife Lynn was shocked when I told her after the race about my premeditated criminal activity in the corral, but I was a heck of a lot more graceful than the young Navy guys standing next to me who did the same thing, but with a small-mouthed bottle and no garbage bag.
Start–>Mile 3: Chaos
Mile |
Split |
Avg HR |
1 |
7:02 |
151 |
2 |
6:39 |
156 |
3 |
6:37 |
159 |
The beginning of the race was pretty chaotic. With the countdown to the starting gun, they dropped the ropes separating the corrals, and everyone pushed forward, creating a very dense mass of runners. I walked to the starting line with the folks around me, then we all started running as we hit the line. It took about 1:20 between the gun and when my corral #3 hit the line.
Running was challenging at first because it was so dense. I had to concentrate not to kick others, and I was grateful not to be kicked myself. There was no way to select any specific pace–we all just had to go with the flow. So, despite the fact that the race starts with a decent downhill, it was impossible to take advantage of it for a fast split. It was fun, however, getting high fives from the kids on the left side of the road. It was surprising to see tens of people running off the course to find a tree; I guess they didn’t know the Gatorade bottle trick.
While I am usually pretty good about being able to estimate a mile split in a race, I had no idea what to expect when I looked at my watch at the first mile marker. I was, however, surprised to see 7:02. I thought I was going faster, but clearly the jostling was making things seem faster than they were. I picked it up a tad, but it was still difficult to lock in a pace with the high density of runners. The splits for the second and third miles, still slightly downhill, were both faster than I wanted, and in retrospect probably a shade faster than I should have gone at this stage in the race.
The initial water stations were chaotic. My plan was to drink a cup of water as often as possible, so I wanted to hit all the water stations in the early part of the race. With the runner density, people were cutting in front of one another, arbitrarily slowing down and speeding up, and generally getting in one another’s way. I’m sure that dealing with this cost me a little energy as well.
Mile 4–>Mile 13: Groove
Mile |
Split |
Avg HR |
4 |
6:58 |
157 |
5 |
6:38 |
151 |
6 |
6:44 |
156 |
7 |
6:41 |
159 |
8 |
6:47 |
156 |
9 |
6:50 |
158 |
10 |
6:45 |
160 |
11 |
6:48 |
163 |
12 |
6:48 |
160 |
13 |
6:48 |
160 |
By now I was starting to get into a good groove, adjusting pace slightly with the small inclines and declines so as to maintain constant effort. As we approached the 10k mark, things started to get a little less dense, although it was still necessary to be very aware of the runners around us. Realizing that too much crowd interaction sapped energy, I ceased the high fives and only acknowledged the folks who most vocally cheered "go Tread!" when they saw my shirt. I felt obliged to try to give a wave to more of them, but I was really concentrating on the race.
I knew that my mobile support team of Lynn, Cam Ferroni (above) and Lara Ferroni would be waiting for me somewhere around the 10k mark. They had the brilliant idea of hiring a driver so that they could see me at multiple points in the race. I started scanning the crowds for the colorful balloon they bought to stand out from the crowd. I saw them somewhere near mile 7, giving Cam a high five and waving to Lynn and Lara, smiling and happy to see them.
The rest of this section was about holding constant effort and reasonably even pace. I slowed a bit on the uphills and picked up a bit on the downhills. I did a pretty good job hitting my pace goals, but I think my effort was a still touch higher than appropriate: hitting the pace goal with all the distractions, other runners, and water station randomness required putting in more effort than typical for me for the pace I was running. The Wellesley College "scream tunnel" was among the more interesting distractions.
Somewhere around mile 10, the Endurolytes I was carrying in a candy container velcro’ed to my gel carrier fell off. I heard it drop, but I decided to let it go, knowing that Cam and team would be able to give me more down the road.
When I saw my halfway split of 1:28:46, I figured I was right where I wanted to be. Shortly after the halfway mark I saw Sara and Rob Spalding giving me some enthusiastic cheers. At my prior request, Sara had a water bottle for me, but I declined it because I was feeling fully hydrated from my gulps at the once-per-mile water stations.
I thought I would see Lynn, Cam and Lara around this point as well, somewhere on the right side of the road, but then I passed the point where I expected them. I figured that they had decided to skip this viewing point due to traffic, but then I heard Cam yelling from the left side of the road. I crossed over, fortunate that the runner density had decreased enough to allow me to cross quickly. Cam asked "do you need anything?" and I quickly responded "two Endurolytes!" Cam matched my pace while pulling the bottle from his back pocket. We ran together for maybe a hundred yards before he successfully handed off a handful of the little pills, one of which I swallowed while the others went into a pocket.
Mile 14 to Mile 21: Transitional Hills
Mile |
Split |
Avg HR |
14 |
6:45 |
161 |
15 |
6:52 |
165 |
16 |
6:40 |
163 |
17 |
7:03 |
164 |
18 |
7:07 |
164 |
19 |
6:52 |
162 |
20 |
7:10 |
168 |
21 |
7:21 |
171 |
I felt only OK after the halfway point. My quads were sore, probably from the downhills early in the race, and my calves also felt a little tight. I was still nailing my pace, and I mentally prepared myself for the upcoming Newton Hills. The first couple of smaller hills were tougher than I expected, and I backed off on pace which resulting in some slower splits. I was starting to feel a little bloated from all the water, so I decided to skip a couple of water stations. I did dump some water on my head at one of them, which felt good.
Around mile 16 I started looking for my other mobile cheering crew, which included my father’s wife Tina, my step-brother Ed, my aunts Martha and Nancy and my step-cousin Christine. My first view of them was at the top of one of the hills around mile 17 when I saw Christine. I noted she was holding some sort of sign… hey is that for me? Following the sign, I realized that it was indeed for me and that Christine’s father Jeff was holding up the other end of it. I didn’t know that he was coming up for this event, but there he was. The sign was a great touch, with "D3" indicating a commonly used nickname for me in my family (my granddad is D1, my dad is D2, I’m D3 and my son is D4. Yes, we are all geeks.). They had engineered the sign so that they could remove the "3" and replace it with a "2" for when my father ran past later, a great idea. They’re in the photo above with the sign. Note also Lynn’s shirt!
Once past the smaller hills, I knew that the infamous Heartbreak Hill was up next, placed between mile 20 and mile 21. Yeah, it was long. Yeah, it was hard. I was more mentally prepared for it than the previous hills, though, so it did not feel too bad. My split for the mile that included the hill was 7:21, so I didn’t slow too much on it. Lynn, Lara and Cam were at the top of the hill where Lynn took these photos, the one on the right just before I noticed them and the one on the left after I saw them. Cam asked how I was feeling, and I responded "I hurt, but I am OK."
I knew that the course was net downhill after Heartbreak Hill, and I still thought I had a shot to finish under three hours. I also realized, however, that I was nearing my limit. When I saw 2:30 on my watch, I thought to myself "the next 30 or so minutes are going to be very painful." I was now starting to feel thirsty and hot, which I knew was a bad sign. I decided to hit hard every water station from here on out.
Mile 22 to Finish: Fading
Mile |
Split |
Avg HR |
22 |
6:43 |
171 |
23 |
6:59 |
172 |
24 |
7:55 |
169 |
25 |
7:43 |
150 |
26 |
8:25 |
150 |
26.2 |
2:17 |
145 |
Taking advantage of the downhill in the 22nd mile, I laid down a 6:43, but I knew now that the limit was very close indeed. Still determined, I did under 7min for the flat 23rd mile, but my heart rate and effort were too high. The wheels started coming off the cart in mile 24 where I had to spend a minute in a port-a-potty, but at least the rest was nice. Restarting after that undesired break was hard, and I was super thirsty by this point. Either they had no water stations at this point in the race, or I just missed them in my delirium.
At one point another runner tripped and fell about five yards in front of me, and I narrowly avoided falling on him. Many other runners were also hurting and walking as it was hotter than the predicted low 60s.
Now all I could think about was finishing, but it hurt. I walked a small incline, relishing the brief break. The enthusiastic crowds chanted "Tread! Tread! Tread!" to encourage me to start running. I appreciated their support, but all I could think about was "I know, I am trying my best, but this is really hard." I started running again once I crested that hill, and now I could feel the early signs of hamstring cramps. "Oh please, not that too." I further backed off on pace.
About two hundred yards from the finish, my right hamstring locked up. I stopped in my tracks, nearly toppling over. The crowds saw this, and many tried to encourage me to keep going. I started wondering whether I should crawl to the finish, but I knew that bending my right leg would result in that hamstring locking up. Maybe I could roll? Digging deep, I threw up my arms, the crowd cheered, and I started running again–slowly. Passing the Lennox Hotel where Lynn, Cam and Lara were watching the finish, I waved back at their room. Lynn snapped the photo above as I crossed the finish line, somehow managing to lift my arms over my head briefly. It is a good thing that a marathon is not 26.4 miles, else I might not have finished.
Post Race: Hurt
Immediately after I finished the medical staff descended on me. They knew I was in trouble, and I had a conversation with them that went roughly like this:
Staff: "How do you feel?"
Dave: "I hurt."
Staff: "Are you going to be OK?"
Dave: "I think so."
Staff: "Do you want to sit in the wheelchair?"
Dave: "No thanks."
Staff: "Can we get you anything?"
Dave: "Some new legs?"
Staff: <smirk> "OK go get some water."
With that, she patted me on my, ah, lower back, a gesture that said both "congratulations" and "please clear out of the finish area." The photos at right, which Lynn took from the hotel room, show all of this.
With the finish only about a hundred yards from our hotel, I figured that I would soon be gulping down the recovery drink that Lynn had for me. I quaffed a bottle of water and a cup of Gatorade as I walked through the finish area. Next was the silver plastic blanket section, and from there we were routed to the buses to get our checked bags. With each painful step, I was further and further from the hotel. Standing in line to get my bag, the muscles in my rib cage started cramping. This is no fun, since it makes breathing very difficult. I wished I had grabbed more bottles of water.
Finally I got my bag, and now I had to find my way back to the hotel. Seeing my distress, medical staff accosted me many times. I seriously contemplated a stop in the medical tent, but I knew what I needed was fluid, and I thought that the hotel was close. I asked directions of a few policemen, and they pointed me in the right direction. Finally within sight of the hotel, a group of teen girls wanted a photo of me and each one of them–they wanted to be in a snapshot with a finisher. People all over the place congratulated me.
An hour after finishing the race, I finally made it to the hotel gate, showed them my room key, and Lynn was waiting for me with a nice, big bottle of recovery drink. Never before has a recovery drink tasted so good. We got back to our room where Lynn reluctantly helped me to remove my shoes, as I could not reach my shoelaces. I took a shower and then a bath. Cam had suggested an ice bath to aid recovery, and Lynn took real delight in dumping three garbage cans of ice on me. Seconds later I was shaking uncontrollably, and it was pretty clear that sitting in cold water in my dehydrated and exhausted state was not a good idea. So I got out, dressed, and we went down to Cam and Lara’s room to watch other race finishers.
Of course the highlight was seeing my father finish. He had also cramped up, but he powered through it to finish in 5:00:40–pretty darn impressive if you ask me. In the photo at right, he is in the white singlet and purple cap. It was also fun watching the diversity of finishers: the guy who juggled for the whole race, the woman with the fake rear end over her pants, the people who were even more cramped up than I was, the Marines doing the marathon with huge backpacks, and more. We spent the rest of the day hanging out, recovering, and sharing all of our experiences from the race.
Reflections
Knowing I had narrowly missed my time goal, my aunt Martha asked me after the race whether I was happy when I finished. "Yes, I was very happy when I was done" was my response. I was partly joking about being done with the hurt, but doing Boston was a really awesome experience. I was fortunate to have absolutely terrific support from family and friends, and that added a ton to the experience. The goal to have a really memorable life experience was more than achieved.
Some other thoughts:
- Doing a PR in a huge destination race like Boston is really challenging. The density of runners, the logistics, the travel and more all conspire to make a breakthrough performance difficult. If I run Boston again, it will be with absolutely no time goal.
- After two 3:03 marathons with big fades after mile 20, there’s obviously something about my training or race tactics which is insufficient for the full marathon distance. There’s a non-linearity of difficulty in a marathon that occurs in that last 10k.
- There’s a sub-3-hour marathon out there somewhere in my future, but likely not in 2008. I’m switching back to triathlon for now.
- It was really awesome to have all the support from friends, family and colleagues before, during and after the race. Huge thanks go to my father, Lynn, Tina, Jon, Ed, Martha, Nancy, Christine, Jeff, Cam, Lara, Jill Fry’s Team, Sara, Rob, Joy, Mike, the race staff, the throngs of race spectators and everyone else who encouraged and assisted me in the event.